Joan Mathie, 92, had just brought groceries and laundry into her Southold home when a man knocked with a wallet he had found. She had not yet noticed that hers was missing, The Suffolk Times reported.

He introduced himself as Stephan and said he lived in Reydon Shores. Mathie told the newspaper that he left before she could invite him in for coffee.

The wallet was returned on Nov. 3. After The Suffolk Times published Mathie’s search for the helpful stranger, an update on Nov. 17 identified him as Stephan Mazzella, who came forward after the story appeared.